|
What
are the primary differences between adhesives?
The leading adhesive manufacturers
are National Starch, Monsanto, Ashland and 3M. The first three manufacturers
sell their adhesive in batches to film coating companies, such as
FlexCon, Avery/Fasson, Coating Sciences, WH Brady, Labelon, Lamart,
Kroy and Tekra.
There are four popular types of pressure
sensitive adhesives: solvent, hot melt, rubber and water-based.
Due to stringent emission rules, an increasing number of adhesives
use water-based coatings. Fortunately, recent gains in technology
have meant that the new water-based coatings are catching up with
the performance characteristics of the prior favorite, solvent-based
adhesives.
In comparing different adhesives, we
recommend that you look at the following:
- Quick Stick. We call this
"thumb appeal". Does the adhesive appear "gooey?"
Will it stick quickly and easily, even if the application surface
is not clean and dry. In the real world of less than ideal surface
preparation, this is a very important characteristic.
- Low Temperature Application.
The user cares little about the theoretical life of the label,
if he or she goes out in one of the winter months and the only
way he or she can get the label to stick is to use a heat gun.
The downside, though, to most low temperature adhesives has been
that the performance at high temperatures is sacrificed.
- Mobility. The adhesive must
flow well, which is especially important for a rough application
surface. By maximizing the surface contact between the label film
and the underlying application surface, the adhesive's performance
is enhanced.
- Maximum Temperature. A hot
pipe can reach 200ºF. Certain adhesives will soften, then ooze
or lose shear strength at high temperatures. A good test here
is the heated shear test (see below). In this test, a 1 pound
weight is clipped on to a label that, in turn, is stuck onto a
metal plate. The entire assembly is heated to 200ºF. The test
measures how long it takes before the adhesive slides off of the
test rack.
- Adhesion to Low Surface Energy
Plastics. Sticking to metal is much easier than sticking to
a low surface energy plastic (such as polyethylene). Many "quick
stick" adhesives are made specifically for these low surface
energy plastics. Unfortunately, these adhesives sacrifice peel
and shear strength at higher temperatures.
- Peel Strength. This is the
classic way to analyze an adhesive. A machine measures the force
it takes to peel back a label, once it has been stuck onto a flat
surface. Ten years ago, an adhesive having a 3 pound pull was
unusual and costly. The new adhesives have made great strides
in increasing pull strength.
- Shear Strength. This the
second of the main adhesive tests. Here, a weight is attached
to the bottom edge of a label. The label is stuck onto an application
rack. The shear strength of the label is the time it takes before
the label slides off the rack.
- Temperature Cycling. A metal
surface outside can reach a temperature that is 40ºF. greater
than the ambient temperature. By night, though, the metal surface
cools. This constant cycling can lead to premature cracking of
the adhesive. The right adhesive does not transfer this stress
to the base film.
- Water Resistance. Certain
of the early water-based adhesives would curl and fall off if
they were immersed in water. Rain would cause the same failure.
- Chemical Resistance. Other
adhesives may swell and soften after being exposed to a solvent.

Adhesive thickness does matter. From
this chart, you can see that a 2 mils adhesive offers much greater
peel strength than adhesive that is only 0.5.

|